[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
[infowar.de] WT 20.1.02: Army's Wings Make 'Black Hawk' Soar
January 20, 2002
Army's Wings Make 'Black Hawk' Soar
The movie's $3 million deployment is the latest in the alliance of Hollywood and the military.
By Lisa Hoffman, Scripps Howard News Service
Four fearsome MH-60 Black Hawk helicopters swooped in precise formation into the heart of a war-torn North African nation last April, bringing 35 elite U.S. Army commandos into the deadly chaos of urban combat.
All but indistinguishable from an actual military assault, this mission in Morocco was anything but. It was actually a staged scene for the big-screen movie thriller "Black Hawk Down," which opened nationwide Friday.
This pretend mission - a re-creation of the U.S. operation in Somalia in 1993 that turned tragic, leaving 18 GIs dead - also was the centerpiece of what pop-culture historians say is likely Hollywood's most expensive collaboration with the Pentagon in at least half a century.
They say it is the first time, as well, that Army troops have been deployed overseas solely to help make a commercial movie. The Army sent eight helicopters and about 100 personnel, including elite Rangers, to Sale, Morocco, from Fort Bragg, N.C., and Fort Benning, Ga., for the three-month shoot last year.
"We saw this as a way to provide the American public with a better understanding of what we do," said Army Maj. Andres Ortegon, a 15-year veteran from Kingsville, Texas. "The movie does a great job of portraying modern combat."
And it does so at no real cost to the taxpayer, because movie studios are required to reimburse the military for its aid. The $3 million-plus bill the Army sent to "Black Hawk Down" producer Jerry Bruckheimer for the military assistance - which included intensive commando training for star Josh Hartnett and other actors - is believed to be the biggest since the military established offices in Hollywood in 1952.
Maj. Ortegon is one of three Army personnel based in Los Angeles as liaisons to Hollywood movie and TV producers. The other three services and the Coast Guard have similar full-time Hollywood offices, and the Pentagon houses one of its own.
The Army's collaboration with Hollywood began in 1915, with help for the legendary early film "Birth of a Nation." Since then, the Army has "supported" more than 130 movies with everything from expert advice to technical assistance, bases for film locations, transportation, troops as extras and a host of tanks, helicopters and other weapons and equipment.
For the studios, a $3 million bill is peanuts when compared with the virtually priceless realism they get from the use of actual props and backgrounds. The expense of duplicating such items, or renting or creating them through special effects - if even doable - would be prohibitive, said John Lovett, head of Hollywood Military Advisor, a consulting company in Southern California.
"It's a bargain for producers," Mr. Lovett said, pointing to the $1 million Walt Disney studio gave the Navy for its help in making "Pearl Harbor" last year.
For that amount the Navy supplied 20 ships, even moving some in Pearl Harbor to the same places they were during the 1941 attack, and provided hundreds of extras and the use of several aircraft carriers.
In return, the services say they get invaluable free publicity, which benefits recruitment and boosts morale in the ranks. And in the case of "Black Hawk Down," the Army hopes the movie will erase the common perception that the Somali mission was a tactical disaster. The $90 million film casts the operation in a heroic light, concentrating on the valor exhibited by Rangers caught in an unexpected firefight.
The military is selective in doling out help to Hollywood. It reviews hundreds of scripts a year but agrees to cooperate with a relative few. Some are dismissed outright for portraying the military inaccurately or in a largely negative light.
In "Golden Eye," a 1995 James Bond thriller, the Pentagon objected to the script's call for a Navy admiral to betray state secrets, and the filmmakers obliged by making the turncoat a French naval officer. In the 1986 smash "Top Gun," Kelly McGillis' character - the key love interest of the plot - was changed from an enlisted woman to a civilian because officers are not allowed to date enlisted personnel.
The Pentagon has flatly declined to play any part in the making of many movies, particularly several depicting the Vietnam War. The military turned down "Platoon," "Apocalypse Now" and "The Deer Hunter," among others, because of what it considered negative, "unrealistic" premises and portrayals.
Mr. Lovett says the military is remarkably easy to work with and generally inclined to compromise. The Pentagon acknowledges literary license has a place in filmmaking and even will tolerate humor at the military's expense.
"If you ask nicely, most of the time the military is willing to bend over backward to help you," he said.
Los Angeles Times
January 19, 2002
'Black Hawk' Uplifts Military Crowd
Film: The Pentagon is pleased with what it considers an accurate portrayal of the 1993 Somalia incident.
By John Hendren, Times Staff Writer
WASHINGTON -- A movie theater on Connecticut Avenue this week took on the jarring flavor of a combined Hollywood premiere and military officers' bash. Cinema heartthrobs in T-shirts and leather jackets huddled with muscle-bound Delta Force and Ranger vets.
The seats held more brass than the Glenn Miller Orchestra: Defense Secretary Donald H. Rumsfeld, Army Secretary Thomas E. White Jr. and rows of beribboned generals and soldier heroes who sat with Josh Hartnett, William Fichtner and other actors who portrayed them.
Even Vice President Dick Cheney's location was disclosed that night: the Uptown Theater. The occasion was the Washington opening of "Black Hawk Down," a film with a particular resonance in the five-ringed corridors of the Pentagon, where an open gash from the Sept. 11 terrorist attack remains--and where military strategists are plotting a return to Somalia, scene of the disastrous 1993 incident that gave rise to the best-selling book that inspired the movie.
"Black Hawk Down" is an unrelenting recounting of the botched U.S. attempt to nab several lieutenants of Somali warlord Mohammed Farah Aidid. The outcome was the destruction of two Black Hawk helicopters, the deaths of 18 Americans and the still-haunting scene of a dead U.S. soldier being dragged through the streets of Mogadishu by an angry mob.
Most of America finally gets the chance to see the $90-million movie this weekend, when it goes into wide release some weeks earlier than initially planned in order to capitalize on the nation's current patriotic fervor.
The film benefited from unusually close cooperation between the filmmakers and the Pentagon, which saw "Black Hawk Down" as a way to reclaim the Somali disaster as a proud moment for the military.
The Pentagon can only hope that any new incursions in the terrorist haven of Somalia turn out better than the last one. But the film, like the book by journalist Mark Bowden, focuses not on the debacle but on the heroism of the soldiers put in harm's way. It spotlights the Delta Force and Ranger troops who have played such a central role in the current campaign in Afghanistan.
In the film, Delta and Ranger soldiers stagger through Mogadishu's maze of alleys, picked off one by one by Somali fighters who rocket past them in Jeeps, assault rifles blazing. The stunned Americans muddle through, drawing on each other for survival over a day and a night, uncertain if any of them can last until morning.
Not surprisingly, this depiction has won the unqualified praise of soldiers. That's not always the case when Hollywood dons battle fatigues, although Sept. 11 has generally buffed up the relationship.
None of those at the premiere seemed able to find fault, certainly not a weeping Chief Warrant Officer Rodney "Sam" Shemp, who spent 18 hours in a helicopter during the Somali battle depicted on the screen.
"Powerful," Rumsfeld declared.
"It was a very good portrayal of urban war fighting. It is like that," said Sgt. Maj. Phil Prater, who served in Panama. "The training and the togetherness, the oneness, the teamwork in that type of environment was just shown through. You do rely on the person next to you, your battle buddy. And if you don't take care of each other, nobody's going to come back."
The military and filmmakers both used the gathering to poke fun at war-spooked politicians. Sony Chairman Howard Stringer recalled his mid-1960s Army stint in Vietnam, while Army Secretary White mentioned the Army's cooperation with the filmmakers, which allowed director Ridley Scott to film real soldiers and government-delivered Black Hawk helicopters on the Moroccan set.
Bowden said he wrote the story with little formal help from the Pentagon and carefully annotated it because he expected the military to criticize it.
"I wanted to make sure I constructed that book like a fortress," he said.
But he also came away feeling the Pentagon had failed to convey its own story, leaving only the tarnish of a mission that resulted in the U.S. withdrawal from Somalia and a newfound military caution by a chastened Clinton administration. Many believe the U.S. flight from Somalia helped persuade Osama bin Laden, the alleged mastermind of the Sept. 11 attacks, that Americans had no stomach for war.
"The men who fought there, even though they were honored in the military, were tainted by the broader brush of failure," Bowden said. "These military men and women did something very difficult and dangerous at a tremendous cost. And for them to be portrayed as bumblers and incompetents is deeply unfair, on top of all the losses they sustained."
The tone of cooperation between the Pentagon and Hollywood was set when producer Jerry Bruckheimer arrived at the Pentagon office of Army Vice Chief of Staff Gen. John M. Keane and said, "General, I'm going to make a movie that you and your Army will be proud of."
The Pentagon usually declines to help in movies made abroad. But this time it pulled out all the stops for a four-month shoot in Morocco, sending 139 soldiers from Ft. Benning, Ga., and Ft. Campbell, Ky., and eight helicopters from bases in Europe and the United States. Army aviators pilot the movie's Black Hawk helicopter gunships. The soldiers shown rappelling from them were on loan from Ft. Benning's 75th Ranger regiment. Last February, Hartnett, Ewan MacGregor, Tom Sizemore and a handful of other actors learned Army culture and weapon handling at Ft. Campbell and Ft. Benning.
The studio reimbursed the Army $2.2 million for soldiers' transportation, food, housing and laundry.
Mail an infowar -
- infopeace -
de mit "unsubscribe" im Text.